Marisol Way hail and wind loss
Fictional completed Case
Two estimates. $57,448.00 apart. One traceable professional record.
See how two competing estimates became one traceable professional record.
Follow the disagreement through reconciliation, supporting evidence, final deliverables, and the portable Case File.
5-minute overview · deeper detail available
Step 1 of 5 · The disagreement
Two estimates rarely arrive in the same structure
The two positions are not directly comparable as totals.
Position A
Harborline Appraisal Group
$155,118.25Position B
Sentinel Mutual Claims Services
$97,670.25Stated difference
Between the two stated totals
$57,448.00
Why the totals aren't enough
“The two positions do not describe the same scope in the same way.”
The case
- Property
- 4127 Marisol Way, Cedar Grove, TX 76043 (fictional address)
- Loss
- Hail and wind · March 14, 2026
Harborline Appraisal Group
Policyholder-appointed appraiser
- Reviewed revision
- Position A estimate · revision 1 · received April 18, 2026
- Pricing basis
- Regional unit-price database, March 2026 release, with O&P stated separately
Sentinel Mutual Claims Services
Carrier-appointed appraiser
- Reviewed revision
- Position B estimate · revision 1 · received April 22, 2026
- Pricing basis
- Carrier price list, February 2026 release, repair-first scope assumptions
AppraiseTrail keeps both source positions pinned to the exact revisions being reviewed, so later changes cannot silently rewrite the comparison.
You no longer have to remember which estimate version drove the analysis.
Step 2 of 5 · The reconciliation
The hard part is documenting why
Calculating the difference is easy. The difficult part is documenting why a scope or amount was supported in a way another reviewer can follow.
Supported position
$138,038.75
Scope with no material difference
$41,120.25
Scope groups reviewed
5
1 scope group referred to the umpire
Pinned source estimates
Both competing positions are published with this sample. Every page and line number cited below resolves to one of them.
Harborline Appraisal Group Estimate
Revision 1 · received April 18, 2026 · stated total $155,118.25
Sentinel Mutual Claims Services Estimate
Revision 1 · received April 22, 2026 · stated total $97,670.25
Fictional demonstration documents. Only these published sample sources can be opened.
Roof covering and underlayment
Same scope, different pricing basis
- Position A stated
- $71,200.00
- Position B stated
- $38,400.00
- Supported
- $64,850.00
Position A prices full slope replacement; Position B prices repair of two slopes with spot underlayment.
Gutters and downspouts
Scope stated on one position only
- Position A stated
- $11,278.00
- Position B stated
- Not present in this sourcePosition B revision 1 does not state gutter or downspout scope.
- Supported
- $11,278.00
The scope appears on Position A only. It is not priced at zero on Position B — it is simply not stated.
Interior water damage — upper floor
Overlapping scope
- Position A stated
- $22,100.00
- Position B stated
- $16,300.00
- Supported
- $18,940.50
Both positions price ceiling and drywall repair; they differ on painting extent and on whether insulation is replaced.
Detached garage
Same scope, different pricing basis
- Position A stated
- $9,420.00
- Position B stated
- $0.00 (stated)Position B states $0.00 with the note “no covered damage observed at detached structure”.
- Supported
- No supported amount recorded — referred to the umpire.
Position A prices roof and siding repair at the detached structure; Position B states zero for the same scope.
Temporary repairs and tarping
Same scope, different pricing basis
- Position A stated
- No price statedPosition A states the scope but records no price (“TBD pending vendor invoice”).
- Position B stated
- $1,850.00
- Supported
- $1,850.00
Both positions state the same scope. Only Position B states a price for it.
How this schedule evolved — Schedule v3 · Final
- v1 · April 28, 2026 — Initial reconciliation draft.
- v2 · May 6, 2026 — Updated after additional inspection evidence.
- v3 · Final · May 19, 2026 — Final reconciliation; detached garage referred to umpire.
A reviewer can follow the decision back to the record without asking the original appraiser to reconstruct it.
Step 3 of 5 · Supporting evidence
The proof stays with the case
These are the records behind the Gutters and downspouts decision.
Completed field inspection of the dwelling and detached structure
Documents the condition the appraisers actually observed, so the reconciliation rests on a recorded inspection rather than recollection.
North elevation gutter separation and denting
The observation is the reason a scope stated on only one position was still supported.
Exterior elevation photo set
Lets a later reviewer see the documented condition instead of taking the narrative on trust.
Position A revision 1 and Position B revision 1
The comparison is pinned to these exact revisions, so a later estimate cannot silently rewrite the analysis.
Detached garage — no agreement reached
Records that the detached garage scope group was examined and referred to the umpire rather than quietly dropped.
Evidence stays connected to the case rather than becoming a separate file the next reviewer has to rediscover.
Step 4 of 5 · Professional deliverables
The final file is already assembled
The Report, Reconciliation Schedule, and Award are finalized from the same record the decisions were made in.
Case Report
v6 · Finalized May 19, 2026
Concise professional summary of the completed appraisal record.
Give the reader the outcome without forcing them through the working file.
Estimate Comparison & Reconciliation Schedule
v3 · Finalized May 19, 2026
Detailed comparison showing how material scope and pricing differences were reconciled and what supported each decision.
Let an auditor or umpire inspect the calculation and rationale without reconstructing the comparison.
Award
Recorded outcome · Finalized May 27, 2026
Final professional outcome, preserved separately from the supported reconciliation position.
Preserve professional judgment separately from the supported analytical position.
Award and supported position are preserved separately
- Supported position
- $138,038.75
- Award
- $142,500.00
- Difference
- +$4,461.25
The detached garage scope group was referred to the umpire at reconciliation. The Award includes the umpire allowance, recorded separately from the supported analytical position. The Award does not overwrite the reconciliation: the analytical position and the professional outcome both remain readable.
Supporting records
- Property Inspection Record v1
- Position A estimate · revision 1 · received April 18, 2026
- Position B estimate · revision 1 · received April 22, 2026
- Exterior elevation photo set
What the client receives
Clients see the documents selected for them — not the firm's working file.
Final documents
- Case Report v6
- Estimate Comparison & Reconciliation Schedule v3
- Award
Supporting records
- Property Inspection Record v1
- Exterior elevation photo set
Clients receive a deliberate professional package instead of a folder of loosely related files.
A clear package reduces ambiguity about what is final, what supports it, and which version the client received.
Step 5 of 5 · The portable record
The record still makes sense when the original appraiser is not in the room
The Case File preserves the issued documents, the sources they came from, and the lineage between them.
What the Case File contains
- Frozen copy
Case Report v6
The exact finalized PDF, preserved as issued.
- Frozen copy
Reconciliation Schedule v3
The exact finalized PDF, preserved as issued.
- Frozen copy
Award
The recorded final outcome, preserved as issued.
- Generated archive copy
Property Inspection Record v1
A readable archive copy generated from the completed inspection record.
- Source document
Position A estimate · revision 1
The source document as received, unaltered.
- Source document
Position B estimate · revision 1
The source document as received, unaltered.
- Generated archive copy
Contents and lineage list
Records what is in the file and where each item came from.
- Frozen copy:
- Preserved exactly as it was finalized. It cannot change later.
- Source document:
- The document as it was received, kept unaltered.
- Generated archive copy:
- A readable copy produced from the case record for the archive.
How another reviewer follows the record
- Sources
- Exact estimate revisions and inspection evidence
- Decisions
- Reconciliation, rationale, and supported position
- Issued record
- Schedule, Report, Award, and portable Case File
The Case File preserves both the professional conclusions and enough source lineage for another reviewer to understand where they came from.
What changes for your firm
Less reconstruction
Estimates, evidence, decisions, and final documents stay connected, so the file does not have to be rebuilt later.
Easier professional review
A disputed amount leads back to its source revision, rationale, and supporting record without hunting across folders.
Clearer client delivery
The Report, Reconciliation Schedule, Award, and supporting records are issued as one deliberate package.
Ready to try it with a real case?
Try AppraiseTrail on one real caseWe'll provision your workspace and help you through the first case.